Original poster: marionros
If I had to write down all the things that I loathe about the Potter series I'd had to write a book, so I'll just suffice with this little rant.
I've been a keen reader of pre-1960's childrens books and especially british ones. I love the Billy Bunter stories (I adore Quelch!) and have a soft spot for the Five Findouters and the schoolgirl stories (Clarence House and Malory Towers) of Enid Blyton. Poor Enid was heavily criticized, even banned from library shelves, in the '60s though because of her assumed 'racism' and 'elitism' (i.e., she portrayed gipsies as 'unwashed and prone to theft' and domestic servants are usually portrayed as rather stupid)
Yes,her children heroes are always upper middle class who will ask Cookie to send an extra spiffing tea to the nursery and tend to talk patronisingly down to Gladys, the maid, but they are never rude to adults, and they certainly never back-talk to teachers, set teachers on fire, steal from teachers cupboards or read teachers diaries, to name but a few things. But I digress.
There was a lot of racist typecasting in prewar books, of course. I've read several stories where a young British girl is being wooed by 'foreign' men (often French or Italian) and the cleanlimbed British Lad comes to the rescue. You can easily distinguish British Lad from Foreigner. The British Lad is sturdy and has a rosy complexion (Sports, you know. Not the bookish type, although rather good in school. But Sports are more Manly) and the Foreigner is usually dark-haired and strange-complexioned, greasy (pommade! how effiminate! not like our British Lad) and often has shifty black eyes and a hooked nose (especially when it's a Jewish Foreigner)
When I first read the way Snape was described and how Cunning and Ambition was a Slytherin trait, I thought that JKR was going to do a Wave; I thought that she would disclose in the last book that Harry would be found out to be wrong about things, realise that in fact it were the Slytherins who people were bigotted against and show her readers how easy it is to fall for such stereotyping. Hah! Was I ever wrong!
To make a long story short, when I found this funny parody on youtube I had to share it with you all. It seems as if JKR's mind really has been stuck in the 1940's. Enjoy!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JZ0jRuASVEQ
Oh, sorry, I don't know how to link things properly or how to hide text under a tagline (or whatever it's called).