Tweak

InsaneJournal

Tweak says, "monkeybum"

Username: 
Password:    
Remember Me
  • Create Account
  • IJ Login
  • OpenID Login
Search by : 
  • View
    • Create Account
    • IJ Login
    • OpenID Login
  • Journal
    • Post
    • Edit Entries
    • Customize Journal
    • Comment Settings
    • Recent Comments
    • Manage Tags
  • Account
    • Manage Account
    • Viewing Options
    • Manage Profile
    • Manage Notifications
    • Manage Pictures
    • Manage Schools
    • Account Status
  • Friends
    • Edit Friends
    • Edit Custom Groups
    • Friends Filter
    • Nudge Friends
    • Invite
    • Create RSS Feed
  • Asylums
    • Post
    • Asylum Invitations
    • Manage Asylums
    • Create Asylum
  • Site
    • Support
    • Upgrade Account
    • FAQs
    • Search By Location
    • Search By Interest
    • Search Randomly

bluefall ([info]bluefall) wrote in [info]scans_daily,
@ 2009-04-05 14:47:00

Previous Entry  Add to memories!  Tell a Friend!  Next Entry
Entry tags:char: artemis of bana-mighdall, char: nu'bia, char: wonder woman/diana of themyscira, creator: doselle young, series: world of wondy

Nu'bia Then and Now, II of II - Now
Here we go with part two of my Nu'bia rundown, dealing with her infinitely superior post-Crisis incarnation. Free of tokenism, overt sexism, and laughably bad writing, and with an added apostrophe in her spelling to ever-so-slightly dissociate herself from being named for a piece of Egyptian geography (which seems odd to me, since Nubia is a reasonably common real-world name, but presumably Doselle Young knows what he's doing better than I), she was reinvented and reestablished as a character with an actual distinct hook and reason to exist, and a pretty cool one at that.




Back in '99, DC decided to really sieze the hell out of the "apes sell comics" day with JLApe - a big League-centric crossover (and I think maybe a fifth week event) with a bunch of tie-in annuals where the members of the JLA got transformed into apes. Nu'bia's story actually begins there, in the Wondy Annual #8 of all places, as a small army of Grodd's people storm the amazon underworld, and Diana, Artemis and the current Shim'tar of the Bana go after them to kick them out. They're sailing along the Acheron Styx in a lansinar boat, when...



The narration is by the ape in the gold hat. He's a high priest of this particular ape cult, and is basically trying to get all his bretheren killed in order to save his own skin, which is why he set them against Diana, knowing they couldn't win. It's a bit complicated, and not terribly relevant.





Huh. Someone with an odd, distinctive speech bubble just turned that ape to stone. Wonder what that's all about?

Meanwhile, the mines in the water weren't explosive so much as phlebotinum-filled, and transformed that ape that just fell into them into a kaiju.







The art is not terribly clear here, but the Godzilla!ape just turned to stone, apparently at the behest of this new woman standing calmly on the bottom of the river Acheron Styx. They both surface, and she takes the opportunity to berate the hell out of Diana.



So that's Nu'bia. Like Artemis, she won the title of "Champion of the Amazons" (aka "Wonder Woman" in Man's World parlance) in fair competition, giving her a clear place in amazon society and Diana's mythology. Yet her mission is distincty different from Diana's, which gives a slightly wider scope to the idea of the position the three women hold, and allows her to interact with Diana without interfering with or being redundant with her. It's straightforward, rational, well-integrated and laden with potential, as new cast member backgrounds go. Admittedly the at-will Medusa gaze is a bit odd at first, but that'll be explained in a minute as well, and is certianly helpful in putting her at Diana's level of play.

(Oh, and if Nu'bia's confusion about names is confusing to you, you should know it was a plot point way back when that Diana is basically the spitting image of her aunt, except not blonde.)

Anyway, the rest of this is mostly just stuff with the monkeys; they think the rakshasas are their gods and want to unleash them on the world or something, and only gold-hat traitor-boy there knows that his people stole their whole culture from humans and thus they have no chance of succeeding because the rakshasas aren't actually their mythology at all. Like I said before, it's a bit complicated and not real relevant. But Nu'bia does some fun posing.



See? I like how she totally balances out how ridiculous poor Artemis looks.

Anyway, Diana does her Truth thing and forces the apes to see their whole quest is a false hope...





... and with that random and curious new plot thread dumped abruptly into our laps, Nu'bia departs, and the rest of the annual is spent in unrelated plot-focused denoument, the two spiffy new characters Doselle Young added to the mythos left to be dealt with as subsequent writers wont.

The first of the two, the Shim'tar Akila, despite being a pretty interesting character with a very good hook (Oxford-grad Bana raised in Man's World, assigned to lead and protect a people who don't especially respect her), got ignored for the next year or so and then unceremoniously stuffed on a bus, off-panel, about five minutes into Jimenez' run so Artemis could take the mantle (she may be back as of last month, but then again, that was a blonde blue-eyed white chick, which Akila is clearly not, so perhaps not). Nu'bia, however, actually had a chance to get some more care and development, when Doselle Young returned to the title a few months later for a brief filler arc and picked up on that abruptly-left-off Ahura Mazda thing.

Context: two new villains, a mated pair named Dr Echo and Blue Ice, show up in Vegas and start killing people and telling anyone who'll listen that they plan to keep killing people until Wonder Woman makes an appearance. She obligingly does, and snaps Blue Ice's arm, but at the moment we're more concerned with a gambler in a nearby bar.





Diana pwns the hell out of the bad guys, as is her wont, while the disembodied voice of Ahura Mazda mocks Ahriman about his blatant fear of her. Ahriman retaliates by stealing the bad guys right out from under Diana's fists.

Meanwhile, a couple get into an elevator looking for a nice quiet nookie corner and end up quite a few stories down in the Underworld in response to a summoning spell instead.





Look, Nu'bia! Her sword appears to have got shrunk in the wash since the last time we saw her. Pity.







Alright, and that's the rest of Nu'bia's story, which explains the random gaze attack, among other things. I like the way she comes across here; she's got wisdom to impart to Diana, but it reads very much as advice between equals, one friend offering another the benefit of her experience rather than any kind of mentorship, despite the age difference and Nu'bia's history with Diana's mother. This is actually one of the cooler things you can do with Diana's royalty - by default, Nu'bia would have seniority between them, and you might expect Diana to defer to her, especially in a conflict concerning Nu'bia's lover. But as an amazon, Nu'bia actually owes fealty to Diana, which means that, despite coming across a bit like an older cousin, she's got the same admiration and respect for and general inclination toward obedience to Diana as younger-cousin Artemis. (Also, Diana's just that good, but the royalty thing helps, is all.)

Back to the plot. Blue Ice, miraculously healed of the rather graphic broken ribs and shattered arm she got from the last fight, wakes up in the presence of Ahriman, who offers her power (stolen from Ahura Mazda) with which to kill Wonder Woman.







Well, that wasn't supposed to happen.

And Nu'bia doesn't take it especially well, either.





This being a few years too early for more familiar CSIs to have set up shop in Vegas, the guy working the morgue is a morbidly hilarious, weaselly little fellow, who tells them the cause of death appears to be electrocution.





I really tried to icon that last panel for y'all, but I just couldn't make it work to my satisfaction.

Actually, ignoring the SCIENCE, the symbolism here is great. Fire (like Hestia's fire, the fire of the lasso and of Diana's spirit) is often associated with Truth, as is gold, which tells you why the lasso is what it is. But interestingly enough, lightning is often associated with truth as well - inspiration, godly wrath, or pure divine truth, in no small part because it was often percieved to be fire in its purest, divine form (which could have interesting ramifications for Cassie's lasso, if McKeever or whoever wanted to take it that way). In fact lightning is Ahura Mazda's preferred method for starting altar fires in more than one Zoroastrian tale I've read.

Anyway, Ahriman basically makes the same offer to Echo that he did to Blue Ice, with an extra side of "Wonder Woman killed your girlfriend, you really want her dead, man" (Ahura Mazda's golden heart taunting him in its disembodied voice the whole time, of course). Meanwhile Diana and Nu'bia are dealing with some petty bank robbers (talk about overkill).





Echo interrupts.









I do like when Wonders shove gods around. What I like even more, though, is that Diana just totally killed Echo, in about the coolest and most fitting way I've ever seen. Justice for the people he murdered to get her attention, and a chance of redemption and to actually save a life, in the same brilliant gesture. And, of course, it was his choice. That is so freaking awesome.

Anyway.



And that's the last we've seen to date of post-Crisis Nu'bia. Except possibly this panel from Jimenez' run, in which an amazon who seems like she's probably meant to be her is standing behind Julia and drag-queen-Phillipus.



So. Obviously, the whole thing with Ahura Mazda makes her a bit complicated to deal with. I don't know if Zoroastrians write in to entertainment media outlets to bitch about people getting their religion wrong the way Hindus and Christians and Muslims do, but if they do, DC certainly got angry letters over this. And even if they don't, it presents a bit of a story conundrum; if she's running around with him, she's probably a bit busy to be showing up at amazon Solstice parties or whatever, meaning she won't be the most frequent supporting cast member. Plus, petrifying gaze. That shit's wicked powerful. Shamazons would have ended a lot quicker and a lot more unfortunately for the Americans if she'd been leading the charge, especially since we know from Rucka that it works when televised.

On the other hand, though, she's awesome. She's an ally of Diana's, in Diana's weight class, good for all the reasons Fury is good but without any of Fury's sanity or continuity issues. She's got an interesting and distinct powerset that's extremely amazon in flavor, and a strongly mythological story that actually stands in a kind of bridge between the Themysicrans and the Bana. She's a friend of Polly and Antiope, providing an opportunity to get a new, non-Polly perspective on Diana's history and ancestry. She's got a bit of direct, obvious magic mojo, something Themyscira's been missing since Magala got... whatever'd. She adds some diversity to Diana's painfully white cast.

And she fills a genuinely unique role in Diana's life. She's the Jim Gordon, the friend who's both very much part of her world and yet also somewhat outside of it, who's a little older, a little wiser, a little more experienced, but still relies on Diana more than Diana on her, the stalwart ally who nevertheless has her own distinct agenda that won't always 100% overlap with Diana's. She's an outside perspective who will get Diana's amazon issues in a way Clark or Etta wouldn't, but without being involved in them the way Donna or Artemis would be. She could give Diana advice without it coming across as patronizing or OOC, but also without any of the loaded mother-daughter dynamic that would be involved in the same conversation with Polly. She has amazonian responsibilities that don't remotely involve Diana, adding a sense of breadth to Diana's world and providing a potential source of reluctant conflict or plot hooks in the form of pleas for assistance and an exploration of friendship vs duty in purely amazon terms.

Also, hey. Long-term title continuity. It's a thing the Wondy mythos could use.


(Post a new comment)


[info]fwee
2009-04-05 02:42 pm UTC (link)
Thanks so much for posting this. I always wondered what happened to her.

(Reply to this)


[info]mullon
2009-04-05 07:22 pm UTC (link)
I think I liked her when her name was more overtly racist instead of sorta-racist-but-trying-not-to-be-and-failing.

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]bluefall
2009-04-06 01:25 pm UTC (link)
But E'verything i's bett'er w'ith ap'ost'ro'phes!

It would work better if she were a Bana. They already have a "shim'tar," so apparently their language does that kind of thing. Perhaps Nu'bia picked up the affectation from the Mesopotamian mythology she wandered through on her way to Ahura?

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]scottyquick
2009-04-06 08:06 pm UTC (link)
"Nubia" isn't a racist name, there are plenty of black women with the name "Nubia".

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]seriousfic
2009-04-05 09:59 pm UTC (link)
To be fair, you could get around the Medusa Gaze's power pretty easily. If she agrees to play by Diana's rules while on Diana's turf (and going another route shies too close to Artemis's characterization to justify), then she won't use a guaranteed lethal weapon unless it's absolutely necessary. Even if you make it so Diana's no-killing rule doesn't apply to mythological beasts, you can always give them magical protection against it since they're mythological. There's a bit of Power Rangers "why don't they just call in the Megazord first thing?" to it, but in a world where everyone has Superman on speed-dial, it can be lived with.

On to the shallow!

All the Ahriman references are giving me Prince of Persia flashbacks. Now that'd be a fun crossover. Assuming it wasn't set anywhere near Warrior Within.

ARTEMIS'S COSTUME! I know we joke about Liefeld, but it is LITERALLY 90% straps! And hoop earrings the size of my head! And SHORT HAIR? Did she lose a bet?

I love how Nu'bia's costume is 95% plausible, functional Xena cosplay, then there's a set of French military epaulettes just hanging out. Are they in the same union as superhero briefs on the outside?

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]bluefall
2009-04-06 01:43 pm UTC (link)
She does have a ponytail, actually. It's all braided up tight in a way that would require her to either have a lot less hair or be borrowing Atom's dwarf star tech, plus the shagginess of the front makes it kind of a mullet thing, which is even more horrible, of course.

The epaulettes are why I'm not certain the Jimenez drawing is actually her. It's a much more sensible pair of pauldrons, but the absurdity of the shoulders is probably her most distinguishing visual feature.

Diana's costume, though, barring the slightly funky boots, is a huge, huge improvement on standard. It makes me weep how little you'd have to change it to make it a hundred times more tolerable - I mean, is there anyone who wouldn't recognize that costume as Wonder Woman? It's hardly a radial difference. And yet, it has so much more dignity and plausibility and aesthetic consistency.

(Reply to this) (Parent) (Thread)


[info]seriousfic
2009-04-06 02:16 pm UTC (link)
Diana's costume, though, barring the slightly funky boots, is a huge, huge improvement on standard. It makes me weep how little you'd have to change it to make it a hundred times more tolerable - I mean, is there anyone who wouldn't recognize that costume as Wonder Woman? It's hardly a radial difference. And yet, it has so much more dignity and plausibility and aesthetic consistency.

That's it, let it all out. This is a safe place. You can tell us what you want Diana's boots to be like.

Me, I think Mr. Miracle's costume might be better if we got rid of the mask and added a trenchcoat. ::shrugs::

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]foxhack
2009-04-05 10:41 pm UTC (link)
*blinks*

Hey, it's John McCrea, the guy that drew Hitman! And that horrifying issue of Teen Titans Go! I've never seen his art used... like this. :D

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]halloweenjack
2009-04-06 12:50 pm UTC (link)
Don't forget Dicks.

(Reply to this) (Parent) (Thread)


[info]foxhack
2009-04-06 03:09 pm UTC (link)
Aheh.

AHAHAHAHA

Oh man I have to find this now

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]aegof.livejournal.com
2009-04-05 11:49 pm UTC (link)
Artemis. Artemis!
Belts are not clothes.
Belts hold up clothes.

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]bluefall
2009-04-06 01:56 pm UTC (link)
The best part is, even in the height of her 90s-ness, her costume wasn't quite that absurd (and the Imagesque art diminished the effect somewhat, particularly compared to this very straightforward, sensible style), and she'd been wearing far more sane and reasonable clothes for ages by the time this annual came out. Why they reverted her to strappy insanity when she normally looked like this at that point is a mystery for the ages.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]sistermagpie
2009-04-06 11:59 am UTC (link)
Just wanted to say thanks for posting all of these!

(Reply to this)


[info]jupiterrhode
2009-04-07 02:28 pm UTC (link)
Are we ever given a real reason why she has power on par with Diana? Or are we supposed to assume that she got it in the same upgrade that gave her the gorgon gaze?

As much as the character has potential, I wish Diana's current twin sister got more play. One of the things I like about Gail's run, although the way Donna keeps getting referred to as not raised on Themyscira is troublesome.

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]bluefall
2009-04-07 06:24 pm UTC (link)
Are we ever given a real reason why she has power on par with Diana?

Actual reason: Doselle Young missed the whole post-Crisis power-down of non-Diana amazons. My fanwank: Diana got a gift from the gods when she won the tournament, in the form of a magic weapon. Perhaps Nu'bia's gift was the power of flight (and, potentially, the rest of the flying brick set) - either inherent, or as a property of, say, her armor.

the way Donna keeps getting referred to as not raised on Themyscira is troublesome

I would really, really like just a two-page backup in an issue of Wonder Woman that tells us what the fuck continuity looks like post-ICk/FC, and my three major questions would be 1) why and how the hell is she a Princess again, 2) did the Medousa fight and Athena's ascendancy still happen, are Hades and/or Hermes alive, and why the crap are Diana's eyes blue again, and 3) what in the seven mounting heavens is Donna's deal right now, because there are at least three mutually contradictory takes that have all been presented as fact in three different places post-ICk.

Much as I'm enjoying the whole gargarean thing, I don't think I'd have used the Olympians so extensively while the embargo on the Rucka gods lasts. Because it can only provoke questions that can't be answered - the absence of Ares and Hermes thus far is fairly glaring, but both of their status quos were changed so dramatically by Rucka's arc, in ways that can't (unlike Athena's fall in status) be dealt with by simple amnesia, that if they showed up in their pre-Rucka forms it would be just as glaring.

(Reply to this) (Parent) (Thread)


[info]jupiterrhode
2009-04-11 01:37 pm UTC (link)
No, we've seen Hermes a couple times. It's just Ares that's been missing.

(Reply to this) (Parent) (Thread)


[info]bluefall
2009-05-31 01:43 am UTC (link)
Mercury, not Hermes. Very different, in the DCU.

(Also, as I type this now, months after the fact, Ares has finally showed up, in ways that solve nothing and really only provoke further questions, augh.)

(Reply to this) (Parent)

I know I'm four months late, but I was looking for Artemis' eye color and got distracted
[info]scottyquick
2009-07-23 02:01 am UTC (link)
Wait, why wouldn't Diana be a princess?

(Reply to this) (Parent) (Thread)


[info]bluefall
2009-07-23 02:21 am UTC (link)
In re: your search, I'll go into this in more detail when I get around to her World of Wondy post, but Artemis started out as a white chick, with red hair and green eyes, remained so through Byrne, and then was slightly redesigned as more believably Egyptian from circa Luke on up, with her hair sliding more toward auburn than orange, her eyes going more hazel than green, and her skin picking up a bit of yellow/olive color (very little of which improved look has been posted here, I'm afraid). It was an excellent, rational and IMO necessary-for-the-credibility-of-the-franchise change and I'm annoyed by the reversion.

As for why Diana can't possibly currently be a princess:

Nearly Jimenez' first act when he took over the title was to embroil the Bana and the Themyscirans in a stupid and pointless civil war for no legitimate reason, mostly due to the Bana reacting to Polly being the irresponsible useless crapsack he portrayed her as. The Wonders ended this war by abdicating the throne and establishing a democracy, which ended up with Artemis and Phillipus in charge; as of the end of Jimenez' first trade, there is no royalty on Themyscira. Those titles are gone. Hence, why everybody keeps calling Diana "once-princess, once-goddess" and her telling off Io for calling her a princess and Kyle stumbling over what to call her et cetera et cetera. And at no point since have the amazons reinstated the monarchy, which makes sense, why the hell would they? It's not like the tensions that require the shared democratic government are gone, or restructuring a society on that level is a convenient thing to do on a regular basis.

So maybe that storyline got retconned out with ICk, then, okay, and we'll just say it never happened. Except, the problem is, after the monarchy was abolished... Hippolyta died. And we know that that is still canon post-ICk because she was explicitly brought back to life when Shamazons started. And if the monarchy was never abolished, and Hippolyta never died, Diana can't be a princess, she's next in line for succession, she's the fucking Queen. And, incidentally, is also hideously, atrociously, unconscionably irresponsible and covered in fail for continuing to gallivant around Man's World and leaving her people bereft of a leader during the latter half of Jimenez' run and the entirety of Rucka's and 52.

If the second Civil War happened, she can't be a princess, because there is no monarchy. If there is a monarchy, she can't be a princess, because she's the queen.

(Reply to this) (Parent) (Thread)

ah
[info]scottyquick
2009-07-23 02:45 am UTC (link)
Maybe it's like Canada and a constitutional monarchy and i totally didn't use wikipedia to figure out what you call that

(Reply to this) (Parent) (Thread)

Re: ah
[info]bluefall
2009-07-23 02:53 am UTC (link)
No, no it is not. The abdication is explicit. It's not about the people having more power or putting checks on Polly's, it's about removing Polly from power completely. 100%. No royalty. Phillipus and Artemis are the highest authorities on Themyscira post-CWII. Diana repeatedly and explicitly rejects the "princess" title after stepping down. "Io, please, I am a princess no longer, and an ambassador only to them."

And even if it were, that wouldn't solve the "Polly died therefore she must be queen" problem. Like I said: if there is a monarchy, she has to be a queen.

(Reply to this) (Parent) (Thread)

Re: ah
[info]scottyquick
2009-07-23 02:58 am UTC (link)
Ah! Okay, thanks for the clarification.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]bluefall
2009-07-23 02:48 am UTC (link)
* Rgh. That should read, "and Hippolyta still died" rather than "never died." Me type awesome for to make words understood. -_-

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]arrlaari.livejournal.com
2009-04-07 06:00 pm UTC (link)
That coroner cracks me up. "You magic lasso killed her because a golden sliver of a god's heart was lodged in her body. In other words, it was SCIENCE!"

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]bluefall
2009-04-07 06:25 pm UTC (link)
Presumably, their definition for the word is slightly different in the DCU.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]jupiterrhode
2009-04-08 11:16 am UTC (link)
Gold is better conductor than copper? But the history channel had a special on copper the other day and said the only better metal for conducting electricity is silver. So who had the research fail?

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]liarashadowsong
2009-04-10 12:14 am UTC (link)
Wikipedia says: "Copper is the most common material for electrical wiring (silver is the best but expensive), and gold for high-quality surface-to-surface contacts." According to a chart on the electrical conductivity page, it looks like gold, while and excellent conductor, falls just after silver and then copper. But you can get very high quality surface contact with it, even though it's conduction is somewhat less effective. So it looks like the comic fails, but at least they put some effort into it. It's silver that's a better conductor but too expensive, even though gold's still a damn good conductor. Yep. Nice try, but the research fails.

(Reply to this) (Parent)

Nubia vs. Nu'Bia
[info]eleusis_walks
2009-04-14 01:08 pm UTC (link)
First of all, thank you for posting all the Nubia scans.

I have always found the Post-Crisis Nubia (I refuse to dignify the apostrophe) really problematic and disappointing. Obviously the Pre-Crisis Nubia is a product of her time and is distinctly racially problematic, but there's absolutely no reason why a Post-Crisis version of her couldn't surmount that. VIXEN is pretty racially problematic too, and they've handled her pretty well in recent years (aside from those issues with the 'coloring error').

The major problem with Post-Crisis Nubia as presented here is that, in their attempt to defray tokenism, they made her distinctly not African. The Zoroastrian hokum is dreadful and doesn't fit well with the rest of the Wonder Woman cosmology, but most importantly it has nothing to do with Africa. Making Africans something else entirely is not the correct way to solve the problem of racist depiction of Africans. This Nubia should really be a Persian or Median character; there's nothing African about her at all. Obviously a black character need not be defined by her blackness, but this is a character -named- Nubia. She is figured as a representative of her race and continent by her very name, and that cannot be ignored without raising significant problematic questions.

This is all without getting into the elements of the Post-Crisis Nubia that are otherwise disconcerting, such as the fact that she is profoundly bound to a male character (in a way Wonder Woman certainly is not).

I was pleased to see Grant Morrison use a Nubia character in Final Crisis as an alternate universe's Wonder Woman. I'd like to see a new, post-Final Crisis revamp of Nubia in which she acts as an activist, teacher and warrior for the people of Africa the way Wonder Woman does for Europeans and Americans. She's got great potential as a character and could really be a positive force for representation of Africans in a way DC has never really managed; Vixen is African, but very assimilated into American society, while characters like Impala and Freedom Beast have never caught on.

At the end of the day, I'd also really like to see the Pre-Crisis origin restored. Why -can't- Wonder Woman have a black sister? It sounds silly at face value, but it's a profound and lovely statement on the female condition, in my opinion, and now more than ever I think Africa could use a strong female voice in the DCU. Gayatri Spivak says that brown women are tired of white women trying to save them, and that it is time for brown women to be allowed to save themselves. I'd like to see Nubia take up that mantle.

(Reply to this) (Thread)

Re: Nubia vs. Nu'Bia
[info]bluefall
2009-04-15 12:52 pm UTC (link)
The major problem with Post-Crisis Nubia as presented here is that, in their attempt to defray tokenism, they made her distinctly not African.

Interesting. It would never have occurred to me to consider her a Zoroastrian character, any more than I would consider Diana a Hindu character for having dated Rama. She says it herself - Ahura is from a mythology a world away from their own, as foreign to her as the Greek gods are to the average American. Of course, she's not African either; she was born alongside Antiope and Hippolyta and made the Exile with Polly, so her cultural heritage is Greek-derived Amazon, like Diana's.

It seems to me the solution would be to explore the pre-Exile amazon culture, which is one of the major advantages to having the character around as she is here in the first place. Where did the non-Greek Themyscirans, like Phillipus and Euboea and Nubia, come from? We know there were other colonies besides the original Themysciran city-state, so perhaps they were wide-ranging around the whole of the Mediterranean. If Nubia is originally from an African amazon colony, how does that affect her take on and participation in the primarily Greek amazon society? Of course, if they're not willing to tell that story with the Bana, I doubt we'd see it with Nubia, who would lack the same comforting distance of metaphor, but it's a direction that would make perfect sense to take.

Why -can't- Wonder Woman have a black sister?

Well, because it doesn't really fit into the mythos. Diana as the only daughter of the amazons has become a fairly significant part of the story. And while that shouldn't override the concern of making an important statement, I don't think blood relation (or whatever equivalent there is for clay babies) is really necessary for that statement. Cassie is considered family, a Wonder, and Diana's heir, after all, without even having been born amazon. Or, look at the Robins. Dick and Jason were both adopted by Bruce, because there was this sense that that father-son thing had to be literal to resonate. But then along came Tim and his father was fine, for years; he had a family, he had no interest in being a Wayne, and yet all that time, he was most assuredly Very Much Robin. In fact a lot of his fans hated the adoption because it seemed to deny the legitimacy of his Robinhood until then. For Nubia to be as relevant to Diana and the wider DCU as Polly or Donna or Cassie shouldn't require her to also be Polly's kid, by the same token.

Gayatri Spivak says that brown women are tired of white women trying to save them, and that it is time for brown women to be allowed to save themselves. I'd like to see Nubia take up that mantle.

That would be pretty kickin'. Given the Wonder Woman franchise is one of the very few in comics that can get away with being somewhat socially conscious, it would be nice to see that freedom put to the cause of racial justice as prominently as gender justice. And, you know, the intersection of the two, which feminism is depressingly bad at.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]scottyquick
2010-01-26 04:20 am UTC (link)
Angelophile retweeted this!

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]bluefall
2010-01-26 07:26 am UTC (link)
Well hey.

(Nobody better link him to Bobby's CBR column. XD)

(Reply to this) (Parent)



Home | Site Map | Manage Account | TOS | Privacy | Support | FAQs