Tweak

InsaneJournal

Tweak says, "stop ripping off dita, kelly!"

Username: 
Password:    
Remember Me
  • Create Account
  • IJ Login
  • OpenID Login
Search by : 
  • View
    • Create Account
    • IJ Login
    • OpenID Login
  • Journal
    • Post
    • Edit Entries
    • Customize Journal
    • Comment Settings
    • Recent Comments
    • Manage Tags
  • Account
    • Manage Account
    • Viewing Options
    • Manage Profile
    • Manage Notifications
    • Manage Pictures
    • Manage Schools
    • Account Status
  • Friends
    • Edit Friends
    • Edit Custom Groups
    • Friends Filter
    • Nudge Friends
    • Invite
    • Create RSS Feed
  • Asylums
    • Post
    • Asylum Invitations
    • Manage Asylums
    • Create Asylum
  • Site
    • Support
    • Upgrade Account
    • FAQs
    • Search By Location
    • Search By Interest
    • Search Randomly

hyaroo ([info]hyaroo) wrote in [info]scans_daily,
@ 2009-05-19 11:25:00

Previous Entry  Add to memories!  Tell a Friend!  Next Entry
Entry tags:char: scrooge mcduck, creator: don rosa, publisher: disney

Life and Times of Scrooge McDuck (2/2)
And we're back, with the second and final part of my run-through (with commentary) of Don Rosa's marvellous recounting of Scrooge McDuck's eventful life.

(In case you missed it, here's the first part.)

It's my hope to manage conveying that just because the main protagonist is a three-foot-tall duck in a funny animal world, the story is not necessarily pure and toothless kiddie fare. (And it doesn't have to be "erotic furry" to have something to say to adults either. ...Not that Omaha the Cat Dancer wasn't a decent comic, but... uh... well. That's a post for another day, don't you think?)

In any case...



When we last left Scrooge, he'd just struck it rich. And finding the goose-egg gold nugget was only the beginning; five years of hard prospecting, banking and financing several profitable businesses later, Scrooge has gone from prospector to billionaire businessman and is already starting to build what will later become the world-spanning McDuck business empire.

So when chapter nine, The Billionaire of Dismal Downs (15 pages) starts, it's back home to Scotland and the family to settle down for good and set up the base for his world-spanning business empire.

However, it's a changed Scrooge McDuck who comes back to the highlands, and the reception he gets isn't quite what he'd expected.





After several, as they say, hilarious attempts at fitting in and getting the highlenders to accept him, Scrooge realizes that probably the highlands isn't right for him anymore, and that maybe a world-spanning business empire would be better off with its base somewhere else... and so, he breaks the news to the family.





Hortense and Matilda, jump at the chance to move to America, but ol' Pa Fergus, who is getting on in years, claims to be too old and weary to move from what's been his home for so long. And one early morning, Scrooge and his sisters leave the castle McDuck to start a new life in America... and Fergus watches them from the window as they leave...





..well. It's not often we see an actual death scene in a Disney Duck comic, but this has to be one of the better death scenes I've seen in any comic. Made all the better, of course, by the fact that Fergus evidently had a long and rich life, and died happy. He couldn't have asked for more.

But now we get to chapter ten, The Invader of Fort Duckburg (15 pages), which is probably my favorite of all the chapters -- and now we really begin to see the beginnings of the later years, not to mention later generations, of Ducks.

Scrooge and his sisters reach Duckburg and meet several familiar faces -- among them Ma and Pa Duck (later to be known as Grandma and Grandpa Duck), and their three grown children, one of whom takes an immediate shine to Hortense...





And thus, the historic meeting of Donald Duck's parents. Is it any wonder Donald turned out the way he did?

However, the fact that Scrooge is moving into Fort Duckburg gains the interest of not only local groups like the newly-started Junior Woodchucks (whose name Scrooge keeps getting wrong throughout the chapter) and the good old Beagle Boys, who have also moved to Duckburg and remember the young riverboat duck from Mississippi, but it also gets the attention of a certain President in Washington.





Cue the Battle of Fort Duckburg!





And its somewhat bizzarre developments!





In the end, there's not much left of old Fort Duckburg, but not to worry -- some time after the events are over, Beagle Boys have been arrested, and billionaire and President have reconsiled, a new building is raised on top of Killmotor Hill, that in time will be a famous landmark.





The money bin has been eluded to several times before in this series, and here it finally is, fully built and ready to be filled up with the cash from the various McDuck businesses all over the world.

And now, when everything is in place, the business empire started and the "base" established with the money bin, now is when Scrooge seriously ups his quest and goes all out to fill the money bin up. Chapter eleven, The Empire-Builder From Calisota (24 pages), spans nearly thirty years as Scrooge travels the world in his never-ending hunt for profit.

Because now Scrooge has been completely caught up in his greed. It's no longer enough to merely be rich and successful... now, Scrooge has one goal and one goal alone: To become the richest person in the world, period.

And this goal consumes him. He's getting more and more short-tempered and more and more cold-hearted. He's even beginning to skimp on his rock-solid ideals of honesty and "making it square," often taking shortcuts and resolving to cheating in order to turn a profit.

Hortense and Matilda keep trying to get their old brother back, even going so far as to accompanying him on trips to see that he keeps to the straight 'n' narrow, but it's no use. Scrooge can only think about money and how to get more of it, and this eventually causes him to go way too far...

When a tribe of Africans, imaginatively calling themselves "The Voodoo Tribe," refuse to sell him their profitable rubber-plant land for the measly price he offers them (he tries giving them a cent and telling them that it's an invaluable metal engraving of "Great Chief Ayb-Link-Kun"), he loses his temper and resolves to threats, after having insulted their religion. Naturally, this does not make them any more friendly towards him, and he's kicked out of their village.

Blinded by his own rage and hunger for profit, he returns with a group of lowlifes, and they completely destroy the village, smashing and burning all the houses and chasing the inhabitants out in the jungle. This deed is what causes Hortense and Matilda to leave him and break all contact with him... and it's also the deed that brings upon him the vengeance of the Voodoo Tribe.





Meet Bombie the Zombie, who for several years chases Scrooge around the world, trying to extract the vengeance of the Voodoo tribe (causing a few disasters along the way), while Scrooge tries to make new business deals wherever he goes.





With the help of some friendly native islanders in the South Pacific, Scrooge finally manages to get rid of the zombie and can (after roughly ten more years of globetrotting and profit-chasing) return home to Duckburg.

But -- just like before, the homecoming is anything but ideal. If the Scrooge who returned home to Scotland was a changed duck, the Scrooge who returns home to Duckburg (which thanks to the businesses brought in by Scrooge has grown from the sleepy little shacktown to a modern city) is almost unrecognizable, more hardened and spiteful and nasty than ever. This very quickly turns not only the population of Duckburg but even his family against him...









In many ways, this can be seen to be the end of the story. The tale of the poor boy from Glasgow that went out in the world to earn his fortune, and who worked his way up to become the richest man in the world end here -- Scrooge has finally reached his goal... but in reaching it, he has lost everything else.

Most of the family members he drove away, and forgot about in his joy over being the world's richest, he'll never see again. Most of the city people whose praise and adoration he's spat at, will forevermore loathe and despise him for his continued despicable behavior. And the self-respect and the ideals he once had, the things that kept him going through the hardest of times, are gone; everything that matters now is money and his own new status as the wealthiest guy on the globe.

The triumph-and-tragedy moment from the end of chapter eight has reached its total completion here.

Now, there's nothing left but the epilogue.

Chapter twelve, The Richest Duck in the World, (19 pages) opens on Christmas day almost twenty years later, and sees an old and tired and bitter Scrooge who has retired from business, and from the world in general, and lives alone and unhappy in a big mansion in the outskirts of Duckburg -- forgotten by everyone. Matilda and Hortense are gone, as are almost all who would have remembered him from old... even the once-so-famous money bin is just regarded as a curious historical landmark, and few people, if any, remember just what it contains.

Now, the only close relative Scrooge has left is his deadbeat nephew Donald, who has grown up to adulthood in the meantime and is currently the legal guardian of his three nephews: Huey, Dewey and Louie, sons of his sister Della. (Just what happened to Della is uncertain: what is certain is that the nephews first came to stay with Donald after their father had been hospitalized when a firecracker went off under his chair. Though they only stayed for a few weeks at first, the following year they came back for a visit that was just supposed to last "for a few days," and ever since then they have lived with their uncle permanently.)

And this Christmas Day, which takes place directly after Barks's Christmas on Bear Mountain story -- you know, the first story in which Scrooge appeared and declared his hatred for everybody -- the old duck has invited his nephew and great-nephews for dinner.

And the historical meeting takes place:





(The story about "sleeping with bears" is told in Christmas on Bear Mountain. Rest assured that it's not at all as dirty as it sounds.)





Okay, that "Eisner Award" plaque is really a joke from Don Rosa's part... Life And Times of Scrooge McDuck did win the prestigious Eisner award back in 1995, but what the award is doing on Scrooge's wall is anyone's guess.

It's obvious that there's not much left of the Scrooge McDuck of old; the one who travelled the world and worked hard and kept true to his ideals. All we have is the frail old duck we see here, who is tired of life and tired of himself and tired of just about everything. Still, of course he can't let anyone get away with implying that he's less-than-rich, and so he takes his young relatives out on a trip to show just how rich he really is.

But, of course, it's not a good idea to brag too much about how rich you really are, especially when it turns out you've been followed by some old enemies in disguise.





Yep -- for the third and final time in the series, Scrooge meets the Beagle Boys -- or rather, Beagle Boys: The Next Generation. Captain Blackheart Beagle (now known as Grandpa Beagle) has brought his grandsons in to once again try to commit dastardly thieving deeds.

And this is when it happens; the last big turnaround of Scrooge's life. When the Beagles make away with several bags of money, and Scrooge feels too old and sick and tired of it all to follow, it's Donald's sarcastic comments that brings him over the edge: Don completely refuses to believe that "rich old uncle Scrooge" could ever have been the great adventurer and hard worker that he claims.

And possibly, this is the last straw. The final insult. Scrooge may be old and frail, but he is still Scrooge McDuck, dammit, and he's not going to let anyone get away with stealing from him -- or spread doubts about his glorious past!

The chase is on!




After an impressive display of using old tricks and half-forgotten knowledge to completely trounce the Beagles and save the fortune, Scrooge goes into what can only be described as a post-high downer and laments what a sad shadow of his glorious past life he now leads.

Luckily, his three great-nephews know all about how to handle difficult uncles.









And as we close on the story (and get ready for many, many more adventures in the future), it is with the firm and secure knowledge that Scrooge McDuck, when all is said and done, really did become a truly rich man in the end. But his greatest wealth isn't the three cubic acres of money, but the well of adventures and memories that he's collected over a long and eventful life.

It took a long time for him to truly figure out and appreciate this, and he lost sight of it sometimes, but he has regained it -- and with it also his sense of adventure and thirst for new experiences. And while Donald doesn't quite understand it yet, his nephews do... and we know that all four of them will have their lives enrichened greatly by their newly-revitalized old uncle.

Scrooge will never be a generous man. He'll always be greedy, miserly, short-tempered and hard-hearted... but he'll also forevermore be a great adventurer and explorer. And his new family, so much more inclined to join in on his adventures than his old one did, will continue to have a positive effect on him and make sure he doesn't lose sight of his ideals again.

It's the best sort of ending to a long story, namely the promise of a new beginning.




And that's it. I've gone through the entire twelve-part, two-hundred-plus page story of Scrooge McDuck's life. Don Rosa would later on revisit the young Scrooge in additional tales of his past, with stories he didn't get around to include in this series (most notably the real story about Scrooge and Glittering Goldie, which was deemed to not fit in here but made for two additional stories that really explored the characters and the circumstances), but these aren't part of the main story -- they're "bonus material," additional information.

The main story is what I've shown you here: One of the most thoroughly-researched (both from Barks comics and from actual history), ambitious, well-told and decidedly adult Disney Duck tale... for anyone who realizes that you don't need bloody murder and graphic sex for a good story, for anyone who realized that "kid-friendly" doesn't necessarily mean "childish" or "worthless"... and for anyone who just appreciate a good, solid adventure story about the struggle for greatness.

Any questions? ^_^



(Post a new comment)


[info]icon_uk
2009-05-19 08:04 am UTC (link)
Excuse me, I think I have something in my eye... sniff sniff... That was beautiful!

The peaceful demise of Fergus, the courtship of Quackmore and Hortense, marvellous stuff. And I LOVED little Donald taking a suitably childish revenge on the man who was so nasty to his Mum and Dad (So much so I'll forgive Scrooge his more childish and less forgiveable payback)

And Hubert, Deuteronomy and Louis (To give them their full names) are adorable here!

(Reply to this)


[info]hyperactivator
2009-05-19 08:26 am UTC (link)
Thank you. This was so cool.

(Reply to this)


[info]arilou_skiff
2009-05-19 08:31 am UTC (link)
*sniff* beautiful.

I love that bit Hortense :p

(Reply to this)


[info]silicone_soul
2009-05-19 09:12 am UTC (link)
The Life & Times Companion is also an excellent piece, particularly the couple of stories focusing on Scrooge and Goldie. It's too bad I don't have the English edition to scan.

(Reply to this)


[info]ulf_boehnke
2009-05-19 10:05 am UTC (link)
I wonder if they will ever publish an official comic dealing with the disappeared relatives.

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]hyaroo
2009-05-19 10:40 am UTC (link)
Well, there is an official comic detailing what happened to Matilda -- she moved back to Scotland and became the official caretaker of Castle McDuck. Maybe I'll post some scans of that sometime. As for the rest of them, doubtful.

Don Rosa did ponder a comic in which Huey, Dewey and Louie tried to find out what happened to their long-lost parents, but never actually made it because, as he said, he couldn't find a satisfying way to end it. If they found their parents, then it would be unrealistic for them to go on living with Donald, and there's no way the Disney status quo would accept that they suddenly didn't live with their uncle anymore. If they found them and for some reason discovered they'd be better off with Donald, it'd make for a fairly weird story and the censors probably wouldn't allow it either. If they found their parents were dead, that would make for a bleak and depressing ending that didn't fit the comic. And if they didn't find their parents at all, it'd be a pretty pointless story.

That said... when I said it was uncertain what happened to Della Duck, Donald's sister and HD&L's mother, I meant officially. I actually happen to know a bit more about the subject, but I didn't mention it in the post itself because it didn't really have anything to do with the story. But, I'll tell it here:

Back in 1994, Carl Barks (who was 93 at the time) was on a tour of Europe and among other places came to Norway for a meeting with the fans, receiving the "Sproing" award (annual Norwegian award for best comic) and an informal Q&A. As a junior member of the Donaldists, I was at this meeting (I was fourteen at the time), and therefore I was present to hear the answer when Barks was asked by one of the fans what happened to Della Duck.

So -- this answer comes directly from the creator of Duckburg himself: Della Duck ran off. She was so tired of raising those kids that she simply shipped them off to Donald, left Duckburg, and never returned. Possibly she's off globetrotting the same way Scrooge did in his younger days?

(Reply to this) (Parent) (Thread)


[info]katsaris
2009-05-19 12:26 pm UTC (link)
"Della Duck ran off. She was so tired of raising those kids that she simply shipped them off to Donald, left Duckburg, and never returned."

Interesting trivia: It's never stated outright but if one calculates the relative dates given in the story, Della must still have been in her teens when she had Huey, Dewey and Louie .

(Last chapter happens 17 years after the penultimate one, and Donald was even younger than his nephews' current age when he last met Scrooge. So Della must have been around 16 at the oldest when she had them)

(Reply to this) (Parent) (Thread)


[info]hyaroo
2009-05-19 01:50 pm UTC (link)
You sorta sense some scandal here, don't you? Add to the "teen pregnancy" story that HD&L's father is the only person on the Duck family tree we don't know the name of... Yeah, kinda makes you wonder if something happened that wouldn't fit in a Disney comic.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]ulf_boehnke
2009-05-19 01:50 pm UTC (link)
Thanks. I expected the answer would be negative.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]arilou_skiff
2009-05-19 02:41 pm UTC (link)
I always assumed she at one point got so tired of her smartass kids that she blew her top permanently (hey, She's Donald's sister, of course she has a temper) and just never calmed down enough to come back.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]janegray
2009-05-19 03:11 pm UTC (link)
Did he say what happened to Della's husband? I mean, I don't think the firecracker killed him.

No info whatsoever on what happened to Hortense and Quackmore, either? It's weird to think of Donald as an orphan...

Also, now Scrooge gets along with his family, doesn't he? So, even assuming that Hortense is dead, why doesn't he at least try to make peace with Matilda?

(Reply to this) (Parent) (Thread)


[info]hyaroo
2009-05-19 03:43 pm UTC (link)
No, sorry to report that he said nothing about Della's husband, and there is no info on Hortense and Quackmore either.

But I think you're right, that firecracker probably didn't kill Della's husband. Maybe its simply was the last straw for him, and he left the family... and then Della tried being a single mother, got fed up with it and ran off as well.

I dunno, that's just me theorizing. It does paint HD&L's parents in a bad light, but in some ways it makes sense that they were originally raised by bad parents, judging by what absolute terrors they were in their earlier days. According to Barks, their parents raised them with extreme permissiveness, so they thought they could get away with everything. Even if Donald is hardly a model parent, it seems he does a better job than their real parents did -- the kids are hardly angels even now, but they are much more well-behaved and considerate. (Joining the Junior Woodchucks probably helped straighten them out as well.)

As for Scrooge not contacting Matilda, it's because he doesn't know where she is. She cut all contact with him and made it absolutely clear that she wanted nothing to do with him, even moving away without leaving a return address. Scrooge didn't even know that the new caretaker of McDuck Castle was his own sister -- only Donald knew, and Matilda made him promise not to tell.

Man, it's easy to get me talking up a storm about the Disney Ducks... side effect of being a Donaldist, I suppose.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]sistermagpie
2009-05-19 10:05 am UTC (link)
I am in awe of this. A life worthy of Scrooge McDuck. That's saying something.

(Reply to this)


[info]katsaris
2009-05-19 12:48 pm UTC (link)
Strange. In my own copy of the story, there are two rows missing, one each in the last two pages you posted: the row that begins "I'm a fossil of a bygone age", and the row that begins "You see what you've done?"

I think the pages actually flow better *without* them -- the kick by Scrooge against Donald makes Scrooge look unsympathetic, and the other row just reiterates over stuff already mentioned.

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]hyaroo
2009-05-19 01:45 pm UTC (link)
You're not wrong. This is the expanded version of the story. See, when chapter twelve was first published in single issues, it was supposed to be only fifteen pages long, like most of the other chapters. Rosa, however, thought that the story was too big for fifteen pages and managed to nag the publisher into expanding into giving it a second page...so the first published version of the story is just sixteen pages.

When the time came for re-publishing the story for the collected trade, Rosa got to expand the story a little more, bringing the page count up to nineteen. The three new pages were added as extra rows in certain places, usually for expanding on a situation or add an extra Barks reference. (The fight with the Beagle Boys is where the expansion gets most noticable,as there was more room for the action to develop.)

If you look at the two "extra" rows in these scans, you'll see that the panel borders don't match completely with the rest -- the line is slightly thinner. It's because these rows were drawn much later.

(For those of you who wonder, the two extra rows in question are: The one where Donald points out the Eisner award, and the one where Scrooge kicks Donald. Neither of these scenes happened in the chapter's original prining.)

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]janegray
2009-05-19 03:14 pm UTC (link)
This was fantastic. Thank you so much for posting it :D

you don't need bloody murder and graphic sex for a good story

AMEN.

(Reply to this)


[info]foppet
2009-05-19 08:46 pm UTC (link)
As they say in the tiki room: Applaud! Applaud!

This was so great. I've been trying to get people to understand that 'kid friendly' and 'disney' don't mean 'worthless' for years! It's such a pleasant shock to see that someone else in the world thinks so too.

(Reply to this)


[info]dustbunny105
2009-05-19 10:20 pm UTC (link)
Photobucket

(Reply to this)


[info]nagaoka
2009-05-19 11:05 pm UTC (link)
That was fantastic...and beautiful. That death scene *sniff*. I love death scenes that show death as a natural, peaceful, welcomed, and happy end to a life well-lived.

(Reply to this)


[info]dejadrew
2009-05-19 11:27 pm UTC (link)
Is it any wonder Donald turned out the way he did?

Nope. That kid was doomed from the moment of conception.

(Reply to this)


[info]lbd_nytetrayn
2009-05-20 02:36 am UTC (link)
Hmm, always liked the look of the cartoon Money Bin more, m'self.

And what's with the villagers from one panel to the other on that first page? They treat Scrooge like garbage, then wonder why he's so upset?

Any word whatever happened to Hortense and Matilda? You mentioned a Della, which was supposed to be Donald's mother, but...

More of the "Sleeping with Bears" story would be nice to see-- was Scrooge involved in that one at all?

And was Donald's crack about a long-lost ledger alluding to anything else?

Anyway, awesome stuff, and very nice closing statements there. More would always be welcome. :)

--LBD "Nytetrayn"

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]lbd_nytetrayn
2009-05-20 02:45 am UTC (link)
Ah, my bad; forgot who Della actually was, and I saw your answers to the other two above.

--LBD "Nytetrayn"

(Reply to this) (Parent) (Thread)


[info]hyaroo
2009-05-20 04:00 am UTC (link)
No problem. And the money bin presented here is actually the original design for the bin, as it appeared in Barks's stories, so continuity-wise it's the "correct" bin. The sleeker, more stylish bin from the DuckTales cartoon seems to be more inspired by the Italian comics, but it could easily have been built later (there have been enough stories where the money bin got damaged and had to be rebuilt, after all; nothing to say that Scrooge couldn't have improved the design a little).

The villagers are just idiots -- that's my take on it, anyway.

As for the "sleeping with bears" story -- yes, Scrooge was very much involved in that, given that it was his debut story.

And I think the "long-lost ledger" bit is just Donald being sarcastic. ^_^

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]penguinzero
2009-05-22 09:57 pm UTC (link)
Ah, Don Rosa. I'll admit, I don't like everything he's done, but he's very near the peak of his talent in Life and Times. (I think my absolute favorite story of his is Hearts of the Yukon, which has great humor, great characters (especially Sam Steele), and Scrooge and Goldie best displaying the longing that draws them together and the unbreakable pride that keeps them apart.)

I grew up on Carl Barks comics -- my dad had collected them as a kid, and after his mother threw them out when he went to college, he made a point of collecting them again and sharing them with his kids. It's probably one of the most critical things that made me the comic fan I am today. And it's always great to see the good Duck writers and artists getting the respect they deserve.

(Reply to this)



Home | Site Map | Manage Account | TOS | Privacy | Support | FAQs