Youka Nitta
Question about When a Man Loves a Man 
22nd-Aug-2009 01:52 pm

I'm working on a Yoshizumi/Kenzaki fic as part of my "Comeback" series, and I had a question about the end of the WMLM series...

I'm working on the plotbunny that [info]snapelike gave me about "Yoshizumi needs to get laid, soon!" and "what about setting him up with one of the discreet hosts in WMLM?" The premise of the fic is that Yoshizumi and Kenzaki are friends-with-benefits, since neither of them wants a serious relationship--Yoshizumi because he's allergic to romance, and Kenzaki still hasn't gotten over his unrequited love for fellow host Shinkawa.

I haven't read the entire series, but I know that Takaaki and Shinkawa eventually end up together. My question is: does anyone know if Shinkawa quit the Rusty Nail after he and Takaaki became a couple? ("Anyone" most likely meaning Snapelike, I suppose. ~_^) I was assuming that he did, since it would be kind of awkward for him to continue working alongside Kenzaki, not to mention the fact that the club is owned by Takaaki's former lover Iwaki. But I just thought that maybe I should try to confirm that before I finished the story. I can always go AU, of course, but I wanted to try to stick to the canon storyline.

WMLM is an interesting series--lots of complex emotions and character relationships, but I don't like it as much as Haru because I found that I really don't like the two main characters very much. Iwaki is too cold and cruel for me to have any sympathy for him, despite his passion for Takaaki. I suppose there must be a reason why he's so emotionally messed up, and maybe if I knew the whole story, I would like him a little better, but no matter what the reason, it would be tough to forgive him for the way he abandoned Takaaki the first time around.

As for Takaaki...I read the "Last Waltz" series first, so I felt sorry for him, since he seemed to be so vulnerable and unable to resist Iwaki. And yet he showed some steel, too--I think at one point, he told Iwaki something like, "You can do whatever you want to me, but I won't let you hurt Shinkawa," which I found intriguing. But then I found the translation to Book 1 on the Aestheticism website, and he seemed like a totally different character, with a cold and cruel streak worthy of Iwaki (which is maybe not so surprising in hindsight, considering that Iwaki trained him). One of Shinkawa's clients had gone into debt and taken on "shady" jobs in order to keep paying him, and her brother Urushizaki, mistaking Takaaki for Shinkawa, demands that he leave the sister alone. Takaaki basically blackmails Urushizaki into sleeping with him in exchange for leaving the sister alone, even though he knows that the girl is actually Shinkawa's client. (Although to be fair, he does ask Shinkawa to stop seeing her--which is another type of cruelty in itself, since he knows that Shinkawa has feelings for him, and is asking Shinkawa to do him a favor so that he can have sex with another man.) It's fascinating, in a twisted way, but it made Takaaki a lot less likable to me. I also didn't think much of Shinkawa for taking advantage of the girl that way--it's implied that she was working in the sex trade in order to keep giving him money. Although it is hard not to sympathize with him in the later chapters, where he's so desparately trying to win Takaaki's heart.

So it's funny, but the characters that I actually like the most are the ones who seemed disagreeable in the beginning: Kenzaki and Ishii, who were plotting to steal customers away from Schnapps and lure them over to the Rusty Nail. Ishii turns out to be not such a bad guy, and cute in a puppy-ish way, and Kenzaki is so young and earnest and passionate in his attempts to impress Iwaki, and I did like the adversarial sort of friendship that developed between him and Shinkawa, that later turned to love, at least on Kenzaki's part.

Also, what's up with so many of the characters having the same names as the characters in Haru? Is it some sort of alternate universe, or did Nitta-sensei write WMLM first, and decided to competely re-vamp the characters in a different series?


Comments 
23rd-Aug-2009 02:15 pm - WMLM SPOILERS!
MAJOR SPOILERS BELOW!!!!












You know that Shinkawa breaks up with Takaaki in the beginning of #9 to be with Kenzaki who is utterly in love with him? Shinkawa is not the least in love with Kenzaki, though...

Kenzaki is #1 host at the Rusty Nail in ch7/vol9. He continues to pressure Shinkawa into a relationship with him. Takaaki tries to drown his sorrows, and Iwaki (who has seen how he has acted wrongly before) tries to talk sense into him, to no avail.

Shinkawa is to open a new club, Bijou, for Iwaki, so he does leave, although not because of the end of his "trial" relationship with Kenzaki. As Takaaki is stabbed, Shinkawa realises that his feelings for Takaaki have never wavered, and there is no way he will ever come to love Kenzaki. However, the conflicts between Shinkawa, Iwaki, Takaaki and Kenzaki seem to be smoothed out, all Japanese way, before the end at Iwaki's wedding. Iwaki seems to have come into terms with - and admits - that his relationship with Takaaki was fucked. There are reasons: Iwaki is from a seemingly rich family, doctors. He is a doctor himself (or rather have gone to medical school and were to inherit the business. It seems as if the family is very unloving and demanding, confirmed when Iwaki's young nephew shows up and wants to be a host too).

As for the names, YN said she just liked them and had nothing to do with each other. And WMLM was drawn first, in 1997, wheras Haru began in 1998. They are definitely not revamped, because the two Iwakis and the two Katous meet each other at some point in a YN doujinshi.

Also, why do we always decide to write the same things at the same time? *hides Yoshizumi/Iwaki-fic*
23rd-Aug-2009 08:32 pm - Re: WMLM SPOILERS!
Thanks so much--I knew you'd have the answers! ^_^

No, I didn't know that Shinkawa broke up with Takaaki to be with Kenzaki, although someone had mentioned briefly on LJ that Shinkawa and Takaaki eventually end up together. (But I don't mind being spoiled!) I've only read the series piecemeal, from what I could find of the chapters posted on the Youka Nitta LJ and the text translations on Aestheticism. Now I feel even sorrier for Kenzaki, since Shinkawa was with him, but never really loved him and went back to Takaaki. Poor guy needs some loving! (I still want to write that Kenzaki/Shimizu fic if I can ever find the time.)

Doctors--I don't see it as much in manga, but in TV dramas it's a common plot element for a family of doctors to force their children to carry on the family business, whether the children want to or not. There was, in fact, a series about hosts called "Night King," where one of the hosts had left home because he didn't want to follow in the family business and become a doctor! (He was a much nicer guy than Iwaki, though.)

I had forgotten about the crossover doujinshi. That was funny, but I'd like to see them meet under more serious circumstances. *smacks down plotbunny*

And hahaha, we're totally on the same brain wavelength! I want to see your Yoshizumi/Iwaki fic! ^_^
23rd-Aug-2009 08:43 pm - Re: WMLM SPOILERS!
We are so clever we can share a brain! :D

The break up is during a discussion where Shinkawa claims that he doesn't want Takaaki, and he calls him while in bed with Kenzaki. It is after Takaaki's stabbing that Shinkawa realises he's been in love with Takaaki all the time and he breaks up with Kenzaki because he knows he can never give him the love he deserves. Only then he goes back to Takaaki, so he's decent enough as such. Iwaki becomes gentler and more sensible as far as I can read. The mean streak has evened out...

So any love Kenzaki can get is good love. Maybe Yoshizumi can fall a little bit in love with him?

I still want to read that Shimizu/Kenzaki fic. She'd be wonderful to him and he'd appreciate her as she's supposed to be appreciated, I'm sure.

Takaaki and Shinkawa end up being deeply in love and ready to use their lives together it seems, the handshake at the last page is about a new beginning as Takaaki presents himself to Shinkawa.

Yoshizumi/Iwaki is going to be novel length. Yay. Or not. But I need to write something not planned and plotted and I got a bunny. I'll let it run which way it wants. I always plan and plot a lot and I need not to, I think.
This page was loaded May 9th 2024, 12:24 am GMT.