[Sylar] There's still so much mystery to this place...but it can't possibly be her, can it? Even taking into account that people have shown up after their deaths, she was five years old. She never had a chance to grow up. This is all just too much to comprehend.
[Matthew] There's a woman claiming to be my sister...but she died when she was five years old. It makes no sense that this woman could be Shanti.