Caroline
Oh, with BBQ beef! I'm having cravings, shush, don't judge me.
I don't know how it works. I mean, she was from a different point in time to us, an earlier one, and our memories haven't changed so things still happened. I just know he can't feel her anymore.
You talking about the demon's plan to link people in there? Are we sure it won't do something like release Lucifer all over again?
Is he hurt because you offered to go, or because you didn't tell him you'd offered, or because his brother is now doing it and no one talked to him, or because he was going to do it? He can be incredibly difficult to keep track of.