First filter! What? Dude, that movie is like...okay, you know what? We're fixing this. You are coming to my apartment and we are watching this movie. You don't have a choice. You need this in your life.
What I'm getting from all of this is that you should probably consider bailing on all three of these guys and, like Lois is saying, go hit up someone new. You're in a new world. New people. New everything. I say you ditch the messy past and start partying with the oh-so potential filled future.
And, Rebekah, come on. I can be your wingwoman. I have mastered the fine and sophisticated art of back-up for friend in dire need of a lay. We got this!