Has the guy just been around in an elven form for a really long time, or did he take over someone's body? The dark lord from our world couldn't be killed, not really, so the dragon god he went against split him into seven pieces and sealed him in human souls. Logic behind it was that every life cycle would wear away at the pieces of him, though it hasn't been that long since their grand battle in the scheme of things. But the one I faced, he was easier to kill because of the human part he was fused with. Maybe fuzzy feelings will be Buttchin's downfall.
I heard you ran into a scare at your bar during that whole thing too, by the way. You okay?