Picture of the trophy, and/or ability to prove it's yours? (I'm guessing they got the fucker inscribed, but that's a guess.)
I'm going to pause, briefly, and point out that you do actually have a pretty damn solid case, here, against your burglar; you guys pay taxes, you're paying the cops to solve this for you and get your stuff back, whether or not you ask them to do it.
But you can.
If you're completely certain you don't want to, though, I need your photos and a trip to Kinko's.