"Maybe not, first time for everything though," he dragged his coffee closer to himself and didn't even bother putting anything in it before he took a small sip. It was a little too hot on his tongue so he set it aside and focused on cutting into the pie with the side of his fork.
She lingered and he sure didn't mind but he was unsure of whether or not to tease about how he thought he knew her. After all, it was outing himself as well as her so what advantage did he have? He grinned and ducked his head to take a bite, chewed and swallowed before gesturing to her with his fork.
"Besides the famed pie fairy? Not a thing. It's all you, girl. But I bet you get that all the time."