Claire looked suitably impressed when he managed to knock the bottles down, but to be perfectly honest, wasn't really interested in carrying a prize around. However, this whole experience was more for him than anything. It had nothing to do with the shitstorm happening back on the island, so she went with it.
She picked a cat-sized Marvin the Martian doll and they moved on. Claire made it a point to keep the thing away from her nose, and just held it by the torso at her side.