Lily was already pretty much constantly grinning but she couldn't help but aim the smile specifically at him when he smiled at her. But when he said he wasn't she couldn't help but give him a puzzled look as she stepped forward. He seemed so gifted, she could only assume that was what he was. But soon, she found herself smiling again. So he was! But...wasn't? Was that because he was here and not elsewhere? Was he not able to? She didn't know if she could ask that or not, she didn't know him. But she wanted to know. Oh how much she wanted to know!
"Why not?" she asked, giving him a slight look of confusion. She quickly shoved her wand in her pocket, even though it still stuck out, not wanting him to think she was just carrying a stick around. "Sorry, I should introduce myself and not continually interrogate you. My name's Lily. Lily Potter."