Snapedom

Original poster: mary_j_59

I am cross posting this, or rather posting a link to my journal. Sorry it's so inelegant! I will be doing another rewrite and will happily obey if anyone can tell me how to do a more beautiful link. )

Here it is:

http://mary-j-59.livejournal.com/17303.html#cutid1

Original poster: drmm

So, I wrote a rather rambling post/essay about love in Harry Potter using the four defintions of love given by C.S. Lewis, including a bit of my perspective on Snape and Snape/Lily. If anyone is interested, you can find it here.

Original poster: geri_chan

I just came across a great essay on metafandom about "why we tend to blame Lily possibly for the wrong reasons":

http://pojypojy.livejournal.com/94529.html?format=light

The writer tries to take an objective look at who is at fault for the breakup of Lily and Snape's friendship. (Both, in the writer's opinion.)  According to the essay, the fault lies mainly with J.K.R. for the whole "telling instead of showing" thing--e.g. telling us that Lily and Snape are best friends, but not showing it, etc. Our sympathies tend to lie with Snape because we only see the Marauders acting like jerks, although we are told (not shown) that James later matured, and we don't see any real closeness between Lily and Snape even though we are told that they are supposed to be close.

Since we were just talking about "telling instead of showing" on another thread, and I know there's been Lily discussion elsewhere on the community, I thought people might be interested in this.

Original poster: sylvanawood

Don't be shy, post away. As a start, I'm asking the writers amongst you: Will you write Snape DH compliant from now on, or will you stick to your characterization from before and only add new canon magic, and perhaps a few facts?
How about your Dumbledore?
And the readers? What would you rather read, an adapted Snape, or Snape as we knew and loved him from books 1 to 6?

ETA: I think I'll make a summary in a few days, about the results. Your replies are so interesting, keep them coming.