Agreed, although to be fair the Weasleys Boys already helped out a lot. I do see the tons of errors in the cover, but I dig the little details like MJ's freckles, arm hair and fashion mags, the big photo of her and Peter, her facial expression.
It's cheesecakey as hell but there's personality in it. The second cover is less freakish looking, but it's so damn bland and generic. That could be any attractive redhead. It's not MJ.