Mod Note:
I think this is a case of internet miscommunication. I'm not getting haughty from agentoflove, although s/he is being rather insistent. That's probably a result of your suggestion that the comm is populated by free riders who aren't buying the books they're discussing here.
As has been pointed out, I've started a book club on NSD where we'll be reading and discussing trades. There's definitely room for a similar club that operates issue by issue. You've got a great idea. Why don't you put it to the comm and see who else is interested?