Mostly Agreed.
One thing, though; David put this request on the recap page to the issue, as well as mentioning it online, so it was more than likely that the poster did know that PAD didn't want his work posted.
Agreed with everything else, though - I was responding to a poster who laid the blame souly on Peter David, and the point I was trying to make was it's not fair to point the guilty finger at anyone in particular.