Re: Rama
I dunno. I would allow a certain amount of leeway with #2 - if that's a yes, just get an editor to come sit really really hard on the writer, because otherwise we're disqualifying Kelly. And while Bats/Wondy was stupid on every conceivable level and, as ever, did a major disservice to her combat abilities in the name of her playing his DiD, he did great work with her outside of that which I would hate to have missed.
Also, I would add "is she misguided" to the list. Call it a Johns clause.