My guy was over/underweight and picked on by your guy--the hot jock/bully/popular kid--for even just the suspicion of being gay back in high school or college. My guy's back in their home town, where your guy has never left and is newly out and just starting to dip his toe into gay bars and clubs. My guy is unrecognizable and goes for a victory fuck, doesn't tell yours who he is. Later on yours can figure it out, and now wants to have mine again and again, but mine plans on making him beg.
I'd really love it if there could be some character development along with the smut. Threading and maybe some Wire.