This sounds fun! And yeah, what I meant when I said Kurt like character is a guy who is a bit of an outsider who Finn use to throw into the dumpster before joining the glee club, in which your guy is also in. Your guy could have always had a crush on Finn, and only now starts to act on it. Making Finn a very confused teenaged boy. lol.
But I'm not really into the girly type guys, or ones that look super emo...