I think this is a great idea! I do have a question though about this part:
-talking about how you didn't like something in a fic is fine, but NO FLAMING and NO concrit
Just wondering what the difference is between talking about something you don't like and concrit. Is it kind of like saying "I don't like something because X, Y and Z" vs. "I don't like something and here's what the author should have done to improve it"? It seems like this could be a potentially fine line, so I want to make sure I understand the distinction.