older always gets my vote! gym teacher by day, glitter proprietor by night? on top of the other great suggestions, there's: manny montana, aidan turner, john mulaney, riz ahmed, rami malek, tom hiddleston, ben barnes, joseph gordon-levitt, steven yeun, chris pang, scott eastwood, derek theler, william jackson harper, tom hopper, joel kinnamon, winston duke, chris pine, charlie hunnam, daniel henney. some of these are 40/41 irl but could be aged down a bit for rp land.