Following along with the story her eyes went wide with disbelief. No she wouldn't believe that, she'd sooner believe someone roofied him a party and he was having some crazy drug induced dream. The reaping though, that made her pause, leaning in that was a little too coincidental. He hadn't been there for Mag's attack and she hadn't talked a whole lot about what actually happened that night or how she tried and failed to take the soul of her father-in-law.
"What did they look like?" She asked nervously. "White with red plasma, really creepy?"