Annabelle hadn't been creeped out so far. She had been a little surprised that he remembered her name just from her credit card, but then again, she had remembered his, so she hadn't thought much of it. The fact that he was here didn't irk her much, either. The jazz club was pretty popular, so she had assumed that he had come just to have fun.
However, when he wished her a happy birthday, saying that he had read it online, she was a little creeped out. It was a little unsettling that he had looked her up after only seeing her for a few minutes, and when he held out flowers, she was more than a little creeped out.
"Oh!" she said, staring at the flowers for a few seconds before accepting them. "That's really sweet of you!"
On second thought, it was a nice act, and maybe he just needed some friends, so Annabelle smiled at him, smelling the flowers. Besides, he didn't seem like a malicious person at all - in fact, far from that.