...I don't have anything on Anya. Cornelia has agreed to keep quiet and Gino is staying out of the situation. But Anya has already told at least one person about me. [he's 99% certain of it. taps a finger against the cup]
So she had to be seen as unreliable by the people she might tell. [and, preferably, undermine her own confidence, so that she was less likely to start asserting things about him to men she'd known for a week]