Brandon just wouldn't know what to make of Carly's reaction to him so he would either be pissy and tell her to just stay away or he would cheat and use his power on her.
Now Whipper...hahaha...oh he'd see her as a total challenge! I just had to use his icon to reply, sorry! He would show her that there are dark powers available in the land of fae and that pixies are no faeries! Hee hee! (And...he's really more like an overgrown boy than a man)
I can see Tanner identifying with Carly on some level. He had a sucky life really and all the responsibility was put on him. His father was an alcoholic and an abuser.
I think Gideon might find Carly interesting, but he'd be wearing plenty of protection at the same time.
Hahaha...oh yeah, Dano would think Carly was hot and a rage on 2 legs! They could be Alden's little bad-asses. *grin*