"Momentary lapse of judgement. If I knew you were going to act like this, I might have reconsidered." Ha. Not likely. She was way too sexy for him to say no to. But he might have thought about saying no, and that's what mattered.
"What did I do? Get a number for a buddy of mine? Sorry. Bast is dealing with some shit, and I'm trying to keep things from getting worse." Of course, giving him another girls number might not have helped Penny feel better, but it possibly would have pushed his friend into giving the poor girl a straight answer. "And don't bring Emily into this. Sure, she may have come to you, but I'm pretty sure its an unspoken rule that if someone's little sister goes to you asking for advice, you're supposed to tell them about it! What if Laney came to me and asked me about some boy she was making out with at parties? Would you want me to tell you? And don't you fucking say no."