Godric ends up arriving earlier than he initially said he would, and carries in a small sack of gifts. Everything he presents to his friends is hand-made.
For Salazar, a bottle of wine (made in their time's style) and a handmade dagger.
Godric found it most difficult to come up with something suitable for Helga, oddly enough. In the end, since he already had practice making a necklace for Rowena, he made one for Helga, too. (And he says, don't judge. It takes just as much skill to forge a dagger as it does something like this.)
For Minerva: (Handmade, so not as pretty) pendant of Aegishjalmur, an eight-fold spindle that symbolizes order and completion. "Considered to be the greatest talisman for magickal power in the North, it is reputed to help its wearer to create order from chaos, successfully complete all tasks undertaken, and is considered to have protective powers." A note attached explains this, then goes on to add: This reminded me of you, as you are the change you wish to see. The note is not signed. But who else would gift something like this?
A jar of honey. It's a somewhat simple, but also traditional-style gift - in his home village, at least. And he doesn't quite want to deliver a boar to the house of a woman he does not know very well. Silly future customs.. There is not a note attached, since Godric has no idea how to really sign something like this.