He does have kicked puppy look. Theon won because of his arrogant look and the pretty boy face that worked with the history of him living as a girl for sometime. He has that 'I am best' attitude look. I also like picking unknowns though the Baron is an odd exception dont know where that app and thought process ce from. XD
Woah being on codine cough meds makes mye feel weird, I hope that reply made sense.