Would you want it to be with Ollie still in high school? I'd love if you continued to use A. Mack but I don't mind changing Ollie's PB if you want. Or even going with a crossover from another show and making him younger (Dean or Sam Winchester calls out a little bit.) Although I don't have a lot of icons for those types of guys either.
Yeah, I liked Lex and Lana (before he went crazy on her) and then it got bleh to me as he didn't seem like the same guy. I'm much more into Supernatural and House at the moment, and obviously Psych which is awesome ... you should check it out! xD