Barnes and Nobles only guarantees mainstream books, successes, unless they're paid to do otherwise, things that are easy, requiring little thought, unless they're acclaimed or required school reading. I'm guessing Annie's is like a Bookworm? Old, dusty shelves that can't hold anything more, tight spaces and bad lighting? Or maybe I'm just being hopeful. Regardless, Arcadia suits. I've heard the owner can be dreadful, but readers usually are.
I hope you're thinking classic Gothic, and not Twilight. You'd lose the little bit of respect your choice of bookstore has earned you.