I'm not actually against the idea; it can be used quite effectively in a pinch, I agree. But the light curtains detracted from the desire effect, I think. It was [...] Hey, want a job? I'm sure I could talk the manager into letting you overhaul the place.
I'll give a generous five. A six to a few of them. Room for a lot of improvement, in either case. If we're wanting to look at this in an optimistic light.