Really, I'm not even sure where to begin. After reading all that twice it seems that the policy is "anything that might be considered dodgy is an automatic permaban" for everything. The policy for photorealistic art is different from other art, except that it's not because all borderline cases need to be treated like they're hardcore kindergartener sexxing. And all art=porn still, with an added helping of "oh, you fans and your porn!" when people started asking about linking to content that was outside of the ToS.
rachel's comments continue to be a trainwreck in and of themselves. And you'd think that someone who is still purportedly representing the company would try for a visual placeholder that doesn't involve large amounts of beer.
coffeechica has apologized for the comments on anorexia, at least, though there's no word yet on whether or not some parts of the ToS will continue to be more equal than others. And really, burying it on page five is not cool of the management.
(Yeah, I can tell we're still experiencing a lot of crosspost with 07refugees. I'll be opening up tagging soon as I hit the admin panel, so feel free to report in on non-Six Apart related stuff. I'm sure there's plenty of serious business out there. Waiting for you. With binoculars so it can watch you change.)
ETA: Tagging is now open to all members-- you can edit/delete tags and set them yourself on entries. Try for big serious subjects, plz, so it works as a filing system.