Either way is shit, but the problem with the AND HE JUST SNAPPED thing is that, if you go to such great pains to show this guy as being a Billy Batson Captain Marvel mixed with a Silver Age Superman before he snapped, it had better be over something more serious than WAAAHHH MOMMY THE PEOPLE ON THE INTERNET WERE MEAN TO ME, not only because it's an incredibly anti-climactic and arguably OOC reveal, but also because, given Morrison's comments in the book itself, it comes dangerously close to AND THIS IS WHY YOU DON'T MAKE FUN OF YOUR BETTERS bullshit, and I'm sorry, but I had enough of that crap from creators when He Who Must Not Be Named On This Comm responded to criticisms of Frank Miller's The Spirit by saying, and I quote, "Ants don't get to condescend to eagles!"