Hal knowing her rubbed me wrong, too, and her palling around in the Hall of Justice during Final Crisis certainly didn't help, either.
Oh, jeez, tell me about it. >.<
was there anything worthwhile in the Superman & Doctor Light segment?
Hrm, good characterization, incoherent plot. The latter was somewhat rampant to greater or lesser degree through all the stories - the John-Mari-Shining-Knight one was the only one that really held together - so I'd assumed it was just a factor of the setup, but judging by this, it may be a wider trend.