[look from him to the toothpick and back again before snatching it out of his hand to read the paper]
Oh.
... Well I guess that's okay.
[She couldn't exactly kick him for doing something like that now could she? She might even be blushing a little because out of all the compliments he could have given her, well... wait a minute!]
Hey! You call that a compliment? [glaring so hard at you]