Team Jeff!
She didn't have to plead, Jefferson and Hook would have done what she wanted at that point and that much was evident. The Hatter took careful passage of the sword, his free hand still remaining as an anchor to Emma's shoulder. Hopefully it would help couch her up and out of danger along with them.
"Alright," he nodded to Killian to keep ahead of them so nothing would catch him from behind with his hands full, keeping close to Emma and pressing her along back towards the path to the residents. "Back the way we came."
What they were supposed to do with Snow or now continuing forward he wasn't sure. They could tackle that once safely inside. They'd done their part to close one rift, no one else needed to die.