I like that idea, tbh! Icarus would have the impression of a very rude guy cemented in his brain, even if he never saw him again, so to see that same guy a few years later fishing all peacefully would butt against that and that would be even MORE reason to draw him a bunch.
Also he could still be hired later down the line!!! Something to think about.
Picturing Icarus hunched over his screen tablet looking haggard as fuck, and laws sending him a text asking him if he ate. He would SERIOUSLY have to think about it and be like 'ah shit, all i had today was breakfast'. I am pretty sure Icarus' default state is pale and haggard if he hasn't been out of his apartment for a number of days.