"I don't know what to say." He glanced up at her when she told him it wasn't want it looks like, and then he started wondering what it was supposed to look like. He opened up the box and blinked. She..was..
"Uhm. This isn't...I love you, Legs, but I don't think this is... I am not opposed to it, but I didn't think that was your thing." He wasn't using her as an excuse. He'd actually listened to her in the past. "Though, if anyone was going to ask, guess it'd be you." He gave her a lopsided smile.
"Right, not what it is, but if it's not what it is, what is it?" The older Winchester looked up at her, confused more by what he'd just said than what was really going on. He didn't pull it out or try it on, not yet. He needed to know what it was first.