"Yes, I did notice that the smell of the coffee seems to cover anything else. But I couldn't mistake the scent of you for anything." He was back to the dreamy stare, looking at the back of the girl. He wondered if he could clip a bit of her hair. The smell wouldn't last very long off of it, but at least he'd have it for a little while.
"I don't have any idea which of those choices would taste good with what I've picked. Why don't you decide for me? A little surprise."
Eric honestly didn't remember what some of the flavors tasted like. He'd hate to chose something that would be ghastly in his drink and make her more suspicious than she already likely was.