"Yeah! You know us?" He blinked, then grinned. "Are you from Neverland, too? Another pixie, maybe, but you don't have any wings...."
He looked her up and down again, then leaned forward. "Which City? The City. There's only one. And you're stuck here now."
He walked around her, still seeing no hint of anything particularly special. "So... why're you here? Are you super smart, or somethin', or maybe you like, have hidden powers. Or you're just super pretty? S'gotta be somethin', outsiders in the City are all special. I think."