Ted Earley - his first prison jumpsuit and a copy of Earley Warning Signs
Jesse Custer - his father's boots, a dress belonging to his mother, some John Wayne memorabilia, Cassidy's sunglasses, a photo of Billy-Bob, Tulip's gun
Hannibal - The paintings that were in Castle Lecter, his mother's jewelry, Mischa's copper tub and bracelet, all the sketches he did during his time in medical school (including those of the men he killed), family tree.
Jennifer Government- a Malibu Barbie doll. Still in the box.
Eric Northman - His father's crown.
Annie Wagner - Inhibitor spike.
Dexter Morgan - A set of knives, pictures of his mother, a drawing of him and his brother that his brother did.
Piotr Rasputin - Some of his paintings
Aidan Waite- A single, slightly worn, sepia toned picture of his wife and son.
Melody Jacobs- Morbius' coffin, a ring from Nate
Bane - a scrap of his clothing from The Pit
Michonne - A stuffed bunny and a stuffed bear from her daughters.
Macklyn - A lock of Lilith's hair.
Jonothan Starsmore - Complete catalog of his music