She understood the skepticism. She'd been pretty skeptical at first too. It sounded crazy, and Cordelia was pretty well acquainted with crazy. "I know. Sounds insane." Both Superman being there and them being fictional. She sat forward in her chair a little, grimacing at Buffy's question.
"Not everyone? Only people who watched the shows. And not just you. I mean, we're all on it. You, me, Angel, Xander, Willow, Wesley..." She almost mentioned Fred and Gunn, but it wasn't like Buffy knew who they were so she decided not to add to the confusion at this point. "But don't worry. Nearly all of us here who are from other places are fictional here so no one really does the whole judging thing." She took another drink. Fortunately for her, considering some of the things that were ahead in her future that she was absolutely not going to think about right now.