"It is good no matter what." How many times had she indulged herself on it here when she was feeling down or just needed something sweet? It managed to always make things better for a while, if only because it helped take one's mind away from darker things.
After a few moments, Elphaba decided on rocky roads. She saw Claudia going for her wallet. "Ah, no, this one is on me." She stated, stepping up the counter and pulling out her own wallet, ordering her ice cream, then pulled out money to pay for both of the ice creams. Elphaba was feeling nice today, and it was a way to make new friends, which still was odd to her, but she just shrugged it off.