The good news, it didn't look like any of them were going to kill her at that moment. Two good, one demented that wanted to kill her who appeared to be the good ones sister… And her head was starting to hurt. The headache that came when she knew she didn't really know what was going on but she knew she'd find out and it'd probably give her a headache.
It wasn't like Piper hadn't seen different times, but that didn't mean it'd make it any easier. She looked over to Paige as she started to tell her that she was a whitelighter, but she'd said them not us which was ah ugh flag on it's own. When she heard Phoebe's name her eyes widened as her first thought was what if she was kidnapped? What if she was in serious trouble? But Paige seemed ore worried about Piper than anything else. She wasn't evil so if she could take Piper to Phoebe that couldn't---.
All of her quick thinking stopped when the one that was trying to kill her spoke again. The pain Piper felt when she heard Prue died and it was her fault because she couldn't save her hurt her to the point she felt like she was going to vomit right that second. She heard the sister and mommy taken by a whitelighter but that part just seemed too insane to make sense to her. The pain wasn't well hidden on Piper's face as she looked from the two sisters as she heard some of the worlds about how she didn't kidnap, separate…. She looked back over to Paige who clearly was trying to get Piper to leave with her right that second.
"Not until you tell me the truth." She said holding her hands up anger starting to wash over her as she thought of everything she'd just heard. "Are you my sister, is Prue dead? And why the hell does she" She said pointing at Christy. "Want me dead so badly? I don't even know who she is!"