Wands vs. Lightsaber. However, I agree with everything you said. If you think particular wizard and particular Jedi, things do get complicated. And even when you put things in general terms ... I wouldn't be able to immediately give it to one over the other. Which is why, it's by a millimeter.
Now I have this need to see Dumbledore go up against Obi-Wan. I think I'd die a happy fan death. Though, it'd probably buch cooler to see them working together.