Pike was getting the last chocolate bar from the bag when Andrea whipped out the movie. He glanced over, saw what movie she was using to show off her best game show chic, and was instantly a lot more glad he was a good liar. This is gonna be a loooooong day, isn't it? Clearly she wasn't satisfied with just getting a chance to hit me later.
If at any point The Notebook came out of that bag, Pike was going to have to say something. Unless Faith wanted to watch it. Then he would grin and bear it, because he was whipped and every single person on the planet probably knew it, at this point.
Instead he just smiled and glanced to Faith. "I'm good with it if you are?" He made a note to watch both Bloodsport and 300 at some later date to even the scales, given what would likely amount from this movie marathon. Hell, he might have to break out Sin City, too. Especially if The Notebook was in that bag.