Looks like you've got all of the information, but I have found that magic and might do quite well together in the past. Different perspectives and experiences are valuable, especially when dealing with a foe that nobody's ever seen before. My battle style is a mixture of both, but magic-users working together with those without can lead to some quite interesting combinations. Your foe is resistant to fire magic but not steel? Teleport your sword-users behind them and let them jump on their backs. It can shorten a fight significantly if you analyse it right.
Of course, it can also lead to trouble if you don't, but. We all work together quite well, I'd like to think?