Likewise and I appreciate the mutual candidness. It is a pleasure to meet you, even if you're not the Spock that I remembered. I'm afraid that I'm the odd woman out in this situation, since everyone that I recalled is younger and apparently much more impetuous in certain cases.
As for you: You were the epitome of a very logical Vulcan, sir. Unemotional for the most part, self-contained, profoundly intelligent. At times, you didn't seem to appreciate Mr. Scott's expounding on and on about how a warp engine could explode like a poorly cooked haggis, or whatever else his metaphor of the day happened to be. You had the tendency to answer people's observations with the raise of an eyebrow, which could be a little irritating to the uninitiated.
Otherwise, you were a very highly regarded science officer. The Captain considered you a friend as well as a trusted colleague. I believe, according to your Starfleet personnel files, you were born in 2230. Your father was a Vulcan named Sarek and your mother was a human, named Amanda Grayson. You had an older step-brother, named Sybok. That's simply what I can recall, offhand, because I was involved so heavily with the files and scheduling. I regret not having access to the files, presently.
The Captain was more...refined. Like metal made pure by a refining process. It's an interesting experience to see what a diamond in the rough this version of Jim is.
Sir, if I might also make a suggestion? If you're looking for theories and hypothesis regarding what might have actually caused this anomaly, then it might be beneficial to you to have a conversation with those who are more like-minded in the physics and space-time sense. It might break this Captain's brain, but perhaps you should involve him as well. There might be another potential problem that could spring up, but I'll leave that to his discretion if he wishes to discuss that issue with you, if he decides to even discuss it. I'm not quite the same sort of sounding board that you used to be, when he needed different perspectives to look at a situation in progress.
Anyway. Physics and temporal violations aren't my area of expertise. That could have been more easily explained by the Department of Temporal Investigations, who would have a field day with this sort of scenario. I'm at a loss as to why things diverged the way they have, much less why I would recall a later time and places, and even later versions of yourselves.
Merely a suggestion and this is merely an observation: I'm sure you're thinking things over and trying to come up with a logical explanation for everything. Even so, Jim was a bit frustrated by the fact that you wish to remain grounded and realistic where these dreams are involved. I tried to explain to him that it's simply the way you are. I don't think either of you have a full understanding of each other and how to make things work to your mutual benefit as of yet.
I wish you the best of luck. I was assigned my post after the two of you had served together. So in that respect, I'm unsure of what transpired prior to that point. My apologies.