Eyes flashed with confusion at his hand being stopped-what on Earth was the problem now?-and he shook his head at the man's words, "I'm not playing you, Toby, why would I be playing you?" He questioned, letting his confusion show for a moment, letting down his smug act over the man wanting to play along with him. Sometimes he just didn't get Toby's logic. The man was nuts.
Oddly, Chris didn't see the pot/kettle argument there.
His head leaned down so he could kiss the edge of the man's jaw, "Come on, baby. You know I love you," Maybe that was playing Toby a bit, but chris didn't think there was harm in it. He did love the man. He just chose to say it at sometimes when it would benefit him. So what?