I'm keeping Marcus, because I like him. His story will be pretty much the same - rich townie boy, "sick" dad, town clerk who is running the distillery for his father. We'll see if there are any tweaks sans Calix and stuff. He may be even worse in re: wanting all the things.
Selene for sure, fae and mermaid queen. Did you guys give any thought to my mermaids as water fae idea, since there aren't many mermaids in game? She'll still be Grant's daughter and have a crazy Regal mermaid mother out there in the depths somewhere. Again, there may be some general tweaks - she'll definitely be more like current more socially at ease Selene vs. earlier Selene.
John as well - he's still going to be married to Billy's sister on the outside, but they're having major problems and well on their way to a divorce. He and Billy do NOT get along (as of yet) and will get to Neverland post-major bar fight. I think he'll still end up a pirate, but I'm not sure what his position will/should be. Any thoughts?